Readings on Writing (p. 2-15)
Reading Response
Reading Response
“Vocabulary of
Comics” by Scott McCloud
Summary:
In “Vocabulary of Comics,” Scott McCloud attempts to
get readers to consider the thoughts and reasons behind using icons and
symbols. He wants to get the reader to
consider why an author uses different types of icons. McCloud presents his
whole piece through an actual comic. This is very visually appealing to the
reader, and it is also an outlet for McCloud to get his points across more
clearly. McCloud creatively describes the specific reasons for using or not
using simpler cartoons rather than detailed pictures. He notes that icons and
symbols represent ideas and they can be viewed in different ways depending on
the reader. McCloud even draws his own character in a specific way to make a
statement. The cartoon was entertaining and educational- very creative.
Homework Question:
McCloud’s text is very different
from the other texts we have read in this class, but is similar to them in some
ways. It is like the others in the sense that a construct is being explained to
the readers. McCloud explains the comic writing construct of icon and symbol
specifics just as Greene explained the construct of arguments, Kleine explained
the construct of research methodology, Kantz described the construct of using
existing texts to make an original one, and Berger described the cultural
construct of objectifying women through art. All of these articles are also
personal to the author. Greene, Kleine, and Kantz all used personal experiences
and thoughts in their work; McCloud even used himself as a character. All of
the articles bring new light to the world of young readers and writers.
McCloud’s article is different in a
lot of ways. Most obvious is the fact that this article is actually a comic! I
wasn’t really expecting that. As I was reading, I realized that rather than
describing a writing construct, McCloud was more like Berger and described a
“drawing” construct of sorts (or maybe even a reading construct since the way a
reader views an icon was a main point). Berger and McCloud’s articles were
alike just because they were not about constructs that pertained to rhetoric in
particular. I would also have to say that McCloud stands out in creativity. He
really reached out to the readers.
The homework question nicely draws out the main theme of how each author addresses a particular construct. I'm glad to read that you were surprised about the comic!
ReplyDelete